Peace Requires Justice: Navi Pillay’s Nobel Peace Prize and EU’s Rule-of-Law Gap

On 9 October 2026, the Norwegian Nobel Committee awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to South African jurist Navanethem “Navi” Pillay for her efforts to promote peace and international law. The committee chose her, in its own framing, at a moment when international law is under heavy pressure and its institutions are under attack.

That framing deserves to be taken at its word. Pillay’s last major mandate was chairing the UN Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, which concluded in August 14, 2025 that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza and that its president, prime minister and former defence minister had incited it. Israel rejects the finding. Asked about the prize, Pillay recalled being praised for her courage in delivering that report, and replied: “Why would you need courage to speak the truth?”

The committee’s case for Pillay is a case for the rule of law itself. It credited her with being instrumental in ensuring that war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide are prosecuted, and with leading the way towards a more comprehensive global legal order1. It praised her for having “held states and national leaders accountable” And it argued that, amid more wars than the world has seen in a long time, international law has stopped being an optional extra to peace and security and become a necessity.

The committee also placed judges at the centre of that global order, describing them as the guardians of the line between order and chaos. The committee repeated that we need people of courage today “as these same judges are sanctioned, and their institutions are attacked”. This of course brings to mind Trump’s recent criticism of the ICC, but the committee’s language was general, and observers cautioned against reading the prize as a direct rebuke of any single government. But the principle it sets out is unambiguous: legal obligations bind states, including powerful ones and their allies.

Pillay’s career gives that principle a biography. She opened the first law practice run by a woman in Natal province in 1967, defended Nelson Mandela and other anti-apartheid activists, and became the first woman of colour on South Africa’s High Court. At the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda she helped establish that rape and sexual violence can constitute crimes against humanity and genocide. She went on to serve at the International Criminal Court and as UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, and she currently sits on the International Court of Justice in the case in which Myanmar is accused of genocide against the Rohingya.

Europe’s gap: supply abroad, prosecution at home

Our research over the summer found the same pattern in each country we examined: public signals of distance from Israel’s conduct, while the material relationship continues largely intact .

Actor The signal What stayed in place
European Union Commission proposal (Sept 2025) to suspend trade provisions of the 2000 EU-Israel Association Agreement Proposal failed, Israeli goods keep preferential access to EU markets. Some states individually passed sanctions (especially on imports from settlements)
Germany Partial embargo on licences for arms usable in Gaza, announced 8 Aug 2025 Lifted within months for “case-by-case” review; €166.95m in licences granted Nov 2025 to Feb 2026; Germany supplied 30% of Israel’s major arms imports 2019 to 2023
Italy 2024 halt on arms exports; defence cooperation agreement suspended April 2026 Halt applied only to new orders, military memorandum renewed for five years in 2025, state-owned stake of 30.2% in Leonardo, which makes F-35 components used in Gaza
United Kingdom Government said arms exports had been suspended Only 35 of 350 licenes had actually been withdrawn

Germany continues to block a united EU suspension of the Association Agreement, citing its historical responsibility (“Staatsräson”) towards Israel, even though majorities of its own population say Israel’s actions have gone too far. In Italy, government rhetoric has moved from “unconditional support” in 2023 to accusing Israel of crossing a line at the UN in 2025, while industrial ties through Leonardo remain functionally intact.

The UK case shows most clearly why words matter legally. When Andy Burnham apologised in July 2026 for Labour’s Gaza policy, he avoided the terms “war crimes” and “genocide”, whose official acknowledgement would impose legal obligations on the state to act. That avoidance is itself a recognition of the point the Nobel Committee is making: international law has consequences, and governments know it.

The same gap shows at home, where the law falls hardest on those who protest the genocide-supporting arms trade. In Germany, the Ulm 5, who damaged equipment at an Elbit Systems subsidiary in September 2025, have spent over a year in pre-trial detention and face criminal-organisation charges under Section 129 . In the UK, Palestine Action was proscribed as a terrorist group, and more than 3,000 supporters have been arrested, as activists were sentenced on terrorism grounds for property damage for the first time in British legal history

Property damage can rightfully be prosecuted as a crime. The concern is proportionality: counter-terrorism and organised-crime law is stretched to cover protests against weapons production, while the weapons supply itself continues. Speech is policed unevenly too: Germany criminalises “From the River to the Sea” when pro-Palestinian protesters say it, while a structurally identical claim by Israeli officials drew no comparable response.

Peace requires justice, applied consistently

The Nobel Committee summarised its choice in three words: peace requires justice1. European governments will no doubt congratulate Pillay. The more meaningful response would be to apply the standard she is being honoured for to their own conduct.

That means treating a UN commission’s genocide finding as a trigger for the duty to prevent, not as an opinion to be managed. It means ending arms transfers that risk use in Gaza rather than pausing them for a news cycle. It means suspending the preferential trade terms of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, as the Commission itself proposed. And it means applying criminal law proportionately at home, rather than reserving counter-terrorism powers for those who protest the very complicity the commission set out to examine.

The rule of law is not a value Europe can export while exempting itself. The committee chose to honour a judge at a time when judges are sanctioned and courts are attacked. Europe should take the hint.

For further information, see the following references: